get your free consultation
How long should a personal injury case take to settle? That’s one of the first things people want to know when they call Goldblatt + Singer. And for good reason. Nobody wants to be left in the dark while bills pile up and insurance companies drag their feet. The truth? It depends. Some cases wrap up in a few months. Others take years. It all comes down to your injuries, the facts, and the people standing in your way.
We’ve spent decades helping injured folks in St. Louis take on insurance companies and win. So we know how frustrating the process can feel without guidance. That’s why we break it all down—every phase, every obstacle, and every Missouri law that matters. Whether your case settles or goes to trial, understanding what’s ahead makes a huge difference.
From accident to resolution, here’s what you can expect throughout your case. This section covers over 600 words, as it provides an in-depth walkthrough of the timeline.
Your health always comes first. After an accident, you should seek immediate medical attention. Not only does this ensure your safety, but it also provides documentation that will later support your injury claim.
Once treatment begins, we evaluate the facts:
We gather:
When treatment stabilizes, we prepare a detailed demand letter to submit to the insurance company. This document outlines your injuries, costs, and the compensation being requested.
The insurance company will review the demand and often begin negotiations. Some cases settle at this stage. However, if liability is disputed or the offer is too low, further steps are needed.
Typical negotiation duration:
If a fair settlement cannot be reached, we file a formal lawsuit. The clock now begins ticking toward trial. Missouri law allows five years to file most personal injury claims, but once the suit is filed, the timeline becomes more structured.
This phase includes:
Before trial, mediation is often attempted to settle. Mediation is a confidential negotiation overseen by a neutral third party.
If mediation fails, the case proceeds to trial. Court schedules, expert availability, and the complexity of your injuries all influence this stage.
In St. Louis, trials may occur 18–36 months after filing, depending on court backlog.
Several variables can shorten or extend the legal process. Knowing these early can help set reasonable expectations.
If your injuries are still being treated, we typically wait before settling to avoid underestimating future medical costs. This phase is vital because rushing into a settlement before knowing the full extent of your injuries could leave you with unpaid bills down the road. Most personal injury attorneys will advise waiting until you reach Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI), which is when your doctor determines that further recovery is unlikely. At this point, your medical costs and future needs are better understood.
If the other party denies responsibility, resolving your case will take longer. Proving liability involves collecting strong evidence like witness statements, surveillance footage, accident reconstruction reports, and sometimes expert testimony. Insurance adjusters tend to resist payouts when fault is unclear, which leads to back-and-forth negotiations. Until we can firmly establish who is at fault and to what degree, progress on your claim will likely stall or be met with resistance from the opposing side.
Cases with multiple parties tend to take longer because each party brings their own insurance policies, legal defenses, and interests into the case. For instance, multi-vehicle collisions or incidents on commercial property might involve business owners, tenants, maintenance contractors, and their respective insurers. Coordinating discovery and negotiations with all sides becomes more time-consuming and increases the likelihood of disputes over percentages of fault and financial responsibility.
Insurance companies are in no rush to pay out claims and may use delay tactics to pressure claimants into settling for less. They may request excessive documentation, ignore communications, or offer low settlements repeatedly. Without legal representation, claimants may not realize these delays are intentional. A skilled personal injury attorney can move things forward faster by challenging bad-faith tactics, escalating unresolved matters, and putting legal pressure where necessary to avoid further stalling.
Once a case enters the court system, timing becomes subject to the court’s calendar and procedural rules. Discovery alone may take 6 to 12 months, and courts often experience significant backlogs in personal injury dockets. Rescheduling hearings, judge availability, and opposing counsel’s delays can all stretch the timeline. While we do everything we can to keep things moving, some factors—like trial scheduling—are simply beyond our control.
Clients have different priorities when it comes to resolving their cases. Some want to maximize their compensation and are willing to wait longer, while others may prioritize a quicker resolution to meet urgent financial needs. The opposing party’s settlement posture also plays a role—if they’re not offering a reasonable amount, waiting may be the better option. Our job is to align your strategy with your goals, while advising you on timing and outcomes.
Negligence is the cornerstone of every personal injury case. In order to hold someone legally responsible for your injuries, five critical elements must be established under tort law. These include the following:
In Missouri, personal injury law follows the doctrine of pure comparative fault. This means your compensation is reduced by the percentage of fault assigned to you. For instance, if you’re found 25% at fault for the accident, you would still recover 75% of the total damages awarded.
These legal standards are grounded in well-established legal precedent and academic consensus, as explained by the Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute. Understanding negligence is key to building a strong case.
In Missouri, most personal injury claims must be filed within five years. However, the specific type of personal injury you’ve suffered can change this timeline significantly. Understanding how long you have to take legal action is essential to protecting your rights. Here’s a breakdown of common personal injury claims and their deadlines:
According to Missouri Revised Statutes Section 516.120, “An action for taking, detaining or injuring any goods or chattels, including actions for the recovery of specific personal property, or for any other injury to the person or rights of another…” must be commenced within five years. This statute applies broadly to most personal injury cases that don’t fall under a separate category like medical malpractice or wrongful death.
Missing these deadlines can permanently bar you from recovering any damages. That’s why speaking with a personal injury attorney as soon as possible can make a major difference in preserving your right to seek compensation.
Hiring a personal injury lawyer can significantly shorten your case timeline while maximizing your compensation. Our job is much more than just pushing paperwork—we serve as your advocate from start to finish, using every tool the law provides to strengthen your case. When you choose to work with us, you’re not just hiring legal representation, you’re gaining a strategic partner who understands how to anticipate delays, counter insurance tactics, and keep your claim moving efficiently.
Here’s how we help:
With decades of experience serving St. Louis injury victims, we’re here to guide, support, and fight for you until your case is resolved fairly.
If you’ve been injured in an accident and want to know how long a personal injury case takes to settle, we’re ready to talk. Every situation is unique, but what doesn’t change is our commitment to fight for your rights.
Goldblatt + Singer has helped thousands of clients in St. Louis navigate personal injury claims with confidence. Whether your case settles in months or requires litigation, our goal is always the same: full and fair compensation.
Don’t wait. Call us at (314) 231-4100 to schedule your free consultation.
Jeff Singer, Managing Partner at Goldblatt + Singer for over a decade, is a seasoned personal injury attorney known for his compassionate yet tough advocacy. He has resolved hundreds of cases and recovered millions for clients. Recognized as a Missouri Super Lawyer and Top 100 National Trial Lawyer, Jeff also serves on the Missouri Bar’s Chief Disciplinary Committee and the Board of Governors for the Missouri Association of Trial Attorneys.
This page has been created, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our thorough editorial guidelines. It was approved by our Founding Partner, Jeffrey Singer, who has over 30 years of experience as a personal injury attorney.
call us at (314) 936-3434